BFM 89.9

HIGHLIGHTS 
Podcast  >  Enterprise  >  Enterprise Explores  >  FashionValet Fallout: Are GLICs Fit For Startup Investing?

FashionValet Fallout: Are GLICs Fit For Startup Investing?

Kevin Brockland, Managing Partner, Indelible Ventures

11-Nov-24 12:00

FashionValet Fallout: Are GLICs Fit For Startup Investing?

Early-stage investing is inherently risky, with failure a natural part of the process, so was the public’s reaction to the Fashion Valet saga—a RM44 million loss for Khazanah and PNB — justified, or an overreaction? And what role should GLICs and other large institutions play in the venture capital and startup ecosystem? In this episode of Enterprise Explores, we unpack key lessons to learn from the Fashion Valet saga with Kevin Brockland, Managing Partner at Indelible Ventures.

We dive into the challenges, complexities, and strategic considerations for public funds in high-risk startup investing. Kevin also shares insights on the specialised skills needed for early-stage investing, the importance of transparency, and how processes like releasing investment memos and committee minutes may help restore public trust.

We also explore how Malaysia’s GLICs could more effectively support the startup ecosystem by leveraging private sector expertise and adopting successful fund-of-funds models through initiatives like Jelawang Capital.

Key insights from the interview include:

- Understanding Startup Risk: Why the high failure rate in early-stage investing demands specialised knowledge.

- Differentiating Failure Types: The importance of distinguishing between “failure of outcome” (expected risks in startups) and “failure of process” (investment missteps).

- Strategic Investment Approaches for GLICs: Why public institutions may be better suited to supporting startups via grants or fund-of-funds models rather than direct investments.

- GLICs’ Role in Innovation: How Malaysia’s GLICs can enhance innovation by partnering with private sector experts and specialised fund managers.

- Advantages of the Fund-of-Funds Model: How Fund-of-Funds Model, like Khazanah’s Jelawang Capital, can strengthen the startup ecosystem by drawing on private expertise.

- Setting Public Expectations: Communicating the realities of high-risk investments to the public, especially regarding the inherent risks of loss-making and reinvestment for growth.

Produced by: Carol Wong, Roshan Kanesan

Presented by: Roshan Kanesan


This and more than 60,000 other podcasts in your hand. Download the all new BFM mobile app.

Categories:  marketsmanagingeconomycontroversiesinvestments

Tags:  FashionValethigh risk investmentsglicskhazanah nasionalpnbstartup ecosystemventure capital





Play / Pause

Listen now : Today I Learned: What Stories Lie in The Forgotten Valley of Wang...

Today’s Shows



6:00 AM

The 6AM Stretch

Thought-provoking discussions on ideas, people and events shaping our lives.

7:00 AM

World Market Watch

Laurent Lequeu, Independent Market Analyst & Writer, The Macro Butler tells us where international markets are heading.

7:15 AM

Morning Brief

We recap global and local headlines from today's papers and portals.

7:30 AM

Morning Brief

John Zogby, Founder of Zogby Strategies, weighs in on how the US views the latest strikes on Iran.

7:45 AM

Morning Brief

Ng Zhu Hann, Founder & CEO of Tradeview Capital talks about EPF's dividend announcement.

8:00 AM

The Breakfast Grille

Adam D. Dixon, Adam Smith Chair and Director of Panmure House discusses state capitalism, geopolitics, and implications on Malaysia.

8:30 AM

Morning Brief

P. Gunasegaram, Independent Business Writer, examines whether Vantris Energy Bhd’s RM480 million government support is a recovery plan or a bailout.

8:45 AM

Morning Brief

Dr James Dorsey, Adjunct Senior Fellow, S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies, provides the Iran's perspective on the recent US-Israeli attack of the country.

9:00 AM

Opening Bell

(REPEAT) Laurent Lequeu, Independent Market Analyst & Writer, The Macro Butler tells us where international markets are heading.

9:15 AM

Opening Bell

(REPEAT) We take a look at the FBM KLCI as well as regional capital markets.

9:35 AM

Pinnacle Perspectives

Ts. Syed Saggaf Syed Ahmad, President of MOGSC discusses how Malaysia’s oil and gas sector can navigate challenges after the 2025 Petronas Activity Outlook shortfall.

10:05 AM

Open For Business

From one restaurant in 1990 to a multi-brand F&B group, Serai’s journey spans generations. We speak with the family behind Serai Group about capital, growth and what it takes to sustain a restaurant business for over three decades.

11:05 AM

FTA

Hassan Alsagoff (Regional Head of Loyalty and Marketing), Grab

12:00 PM

Enterprise Explores

As the US Supreme Court strikes down Trump’s tariff play, new mechanics for a 10% global tax are already emerging. Dr. Carmelo Ferlito argues that protectionism is a "civilisational retreat" that makes societies poorer and starves innovation. Discover why in this conversation.

1:00 PM

The Breakfast Grille (REPEAT)

Adam D. Dixon, Adam Smith Chair and Director of Panmure House discusses state capitalism, geopolitics, and implications on Malaysia.

2:05 PM

Discovery Hour

An eclectic selection of BBC shows, curated with variety in mind.

3:05 PM

Earth Matters

In one month, Orang Asli communities faced evictions, arrests and logging without consent. Are reform promises failing? Koong Hui Yein, a Programme Manager at RimbaWatch, explains what is at stake.

4:05 PM

Health & Living

Grief is never linear. Some people go through the five stages of grief, but some don’t. We speak to a counsellor about what you need to know about grieving.

5:00 PM

Top 5 at 5

A countdown of the 5 biggest stories of the day, to catch you up on all you need to know!

6:00 PM

Today I Learned

What Stories Lie in The Forgotten Valley of Wang Kelian?

7:00 PM

Just For Kicks

Set-piece goals were the way to go as Arsenal won their battle against London neighbours Chelsea. We review that game, and many others, on this episode!

8:00 PM

A Bit of Culture

Kam Raslan, Matt Armitage and Hafiz Noor Shams sit together to talk about technology's effects on pop culture, reading the manual and books becoming luxury items.